The Mansion on the Hill: Dylan, Young, Geffen, Springsteen, and the Head-on Collision of Rock and CommerceExploring the intersection of music, business, and fame through the lives of Dylan, Young, Geffen, and Springsteen.3.9 out of 5
3.9 out of 5
Hot take
Fred Goodman’s 'The Mansion on the Hill' is a meticulously researched deep dive into the collision of artistry and big business in rock music, centering on Dylan, Young, Geffen, and Springsteen. The book excels at weaving together stories about the transformation of rock from counterculture movement to corporate juggernaut, highlighting the ambitions and machinations of key industry players. Goodman's in-depth reporting brings to life both the rise of major record labels and the behind-the-scenes power struggles that shaped the careers of iconic artists. However, some critics find the central thesis muddled, arguing that the book’s narrative sometimes lacks cohesion and falls back on nostalgia for the lost '60s idealism. While the storytelling is compelling, the analysis can drift, and its cynicism may leave readers with a somewhat bleak view of the industry. Still, for anyone interested in the intersection of rock and commerce, this is a revealing and highly readable chronicle.
How was this take was created?
Pros
Exceptionally well-researched and detailed
Engaging storytelling with fascinating anecdotes
Clear-eyed look at the commercialization of rock
Explores the evolution and power dynamics of the music business
Pulls back the curtain on legendary artists and managers
Cons
Central argument can feel unfocused or weak
Can be overly nostalgic or cynical about the industry
Narrative sometimes lacks cohesion
Some character assessments lack convincing evidence
Key Features
In-depth music industry analysis
Multi-thread storytelling on artists and executives
Extensive focus on the rise of big business in rock
Well-researched historical and industry context
Claim this service
If you are affiliated with this service, you can claim it to manage its details and engage directly a growing community of creators & innovators.