Pirates PressProtecting and empowering independent creators through quality vinyl manufacturing.3.6 out of 5
3.6 out of 5
Hot take
Pirates Press stands out in the vinyl production world for its independent, artist-focused ethos and wide-ranging service offerings—manufacturing vinyl, merchandise, and even running its own label. They’re celebrated for supporting indie artists and ensuring transparent, hands-on project management, with a reputation for strong customer service and creative flexibility. However, some users report quality control issues, such as incorrect vinyl colors, and industry insiders flag that Pirates Press doesn’t actually press the records themselves—they function as brokers, outsourcing the actual manufacturing. This lack of direct control can complicate quality assurance and accountability, raising concerns for those seeking a tight grip on production. Still, their devotion to indie music culture and breadth of service continues to earn them a loyal following, especially among punk and DIY artists.
How was this take was created?
Pros
Strong indie and artist focus
Excellent customer service and communication
Creative flexibility for custom projects
Competitive pricing for independent artists
Broad offerings: vinyl, merch, and label support
Supports and invests in punk/DIY culture
Cons
Acts as a broker, not an actual pressing plant
Quality control issues reported (e.g., incorrect vinyl colors)
Less direct control over production processes
Can be less transparent about manufacturing partners
Key Features
Vinyl and CD manufacturing
Custom merchandise production
Project management and artist support
Runs an active record label
Promotional product creation
Responsive customer service
Claim this service
If you are affiliated with this service, you can claim it to manage its details and engage directly a growing community of creators & innovators.